If your family has lost a loved one due to someone else’s negligence in Atherton, California, you may be facing overwhelming emotional and financial burdens. A wrongful death claim can help hold the responsible parties accountable and seek compensation for medical costs, funeral expenses, lost income, and the loss of companionship. Our page explains the process for families in Atherton and the surrounding San Mateo County communities, outlining how a wrongful death claim proceeds, common timelines, and what family members can expect when pursuing justice and financial recovery through the civil court system.
Recovering after a wrongful death means more than addressing immediate bills. Families often need guidance on evidence preservation, witness statements, and how to document economic and non-economic losses. This guide focuses on local considerations for Atherton residents, including relevant California statutes and local court procedures. We aim to provide clear, practical information about the steps to take after a fatal accident, the types of damages recoverable under California law, and how to begin a claim while managing grief and other responsibilities associated with arranging final affairs.
A wrongful death claim provides families a legal avenue to obtain compensation and accountability when a preventable death occurs. In addition to financial relief for immediate costs like medical and funeral expenses, a successful claim can address lost future earnings, loss of support, and the emotional toll on survivors. For residents of Atherton, pursuing such a claim can also encourage safer practices by responsible parties and organizations. Engaging in the process helps families secure resources needed for recovery and planning, enabling a focus on healing while the legal matter moves toward resolution through negotiation or litigation if settlement is not reached.
Law Republic APC represents families throughout California, including Atherton and San Mateo County, in wrongful death and personal injury matters. We provide attentive guidance through each stage of a claim, focusing on thorough investigation, careful documentation of damages, and persistent advocacy on behalf of clients. Our team prioritizes communication, keeping families informed of progress and realistic options. We work to obtain compensation that addresses both tangible losses like lost income and medical bills and intangible harms such as loss of companionship, always aiming to ease the administrative and legal burdens families face during a difficult time.
A wrongful death claim is a civil action brought when a person dies because of another party’s wrongful act, neglect, or default. In California, surviving family members or estate representatives may file a claim seeking monetary damages for funeral costs, medical expenses prior to death, loss of financial support, and loss of companionship. Local factors in Atherton, such as commuting patterns and regional health care considerations, can influence evidence and valuation. The claim timeline varies, and understanding statutory deadlines, available damages, and the roles of plaintiffs and defendants helps families make informed decisions about pursuing legal remedies and preserving key evidence early in the process.
Filing a wrongful death case involves compiling medical records, police reports, witness statements, and financial documentation to prove negligence and damages. California law limits who may bring a claim and outlines the types of recoverable damages; typically, spouses, domestic partners, children, and certain dependents have standing. An estate representative may also pursue claims on behalf of survivors. For Atherton families, cooperating with local authorities and health providers, promptly obtaining records, and documenting the deceased’s role in household finances strengthen a claim. Timely action is essential to meet legal time limits and to preserve evidence that could be critical for settlement or trial.
Wrongful death occurs when a person dies due to another party’s negligent or intentional act. This civil claim differs from criminal proceedings, focusing on compensating survivors rather than punishing offenders. In Atherton, common wrongful death scenarios include motor vehicle collisions, medical negligence, or dangerous property conditions. To succeed, plaintiffs generally must show the defendant owed a duty of care, breached that duty, and caused the death and resulting damages. Understanding these elements helps families and estate representatives organize proof, identify potential defendants, and prepare for negotiations or trial to secure compensation for the losses suffered.
A wrongful death claim typically requires establishing duty, breach, causation, and damages. The process begins with investigation and evidence collection, followed by filing a complaint within California’s statute of limitations. Discovery exchanges allow both sides to obtain records and testimony. Many cases resolve through negotiation or mediation, while some proceed to trial if settlement is not achieved. For Atherton families, timelines can be affected by local court schedules and the complexity of medical or accident evidence. Preparing early documentation and working with investigators and forensic professionals improves the chance of a thorough presentation of damages and liability.
Navigating a wrongful death claim involves several legal and medical terms that may be unfamiliar. Understanding phrases like ‘survival action,’ ‘economic damages,’ ‘non-economic damages,’ and ‘statute of limitations’ helps families follow the process and make informed decisions. This glossary provides concise explanations of the most common terms relevant to Atherton residents pursuing a claim. Clear definitions make it easier to communicate with attorneys, medical providers, and insurers, and to prepare the documentation needed to support claims for compensation tied to both tangible losses and intangible harms suffered by survivors.
Economic damages refer to measurable financial losses that result from a wrongful death, including medical bills related to the injury prior to death, funeral and burial expenses, and lost wages or future earnings the deceased would have provided. For Atherton families, calculating economic damages often involves gathering tax returns, employment records, and expert projections of future income. These figures form the basis for claims seeking reimbursement of actual monetary losses, which can be supported by documentation and testimony from financial and vocational professionals to demonstrate the financial impact on surviving family members.
Non-economic damages compensate for intangible losses that do not have precise monetary values, such as loss of companionship, emotional distress, loss of guidance, and diminution of quality of life resulting from the death. Courts and insurers consider these harms in determining fair compensation for survivors. In Atherton wrongful death claims, presenting persuasive evidence of the deceased’s role in family life and the emotional impact of the loss helps justify non-economic awards, which are often calculated by reviewing similar cases and factoring in the deceased’s relationship to the claimants and their contributions to family life.
A survival action is a claim brought on behalf of the deceased person’s estate for harms suffered by the decedent prior to death, such as pain and suffering or medical expenses incurred after the injury but before death. This action allows the estate to recover those losses and distribute proceeds to beneficiaries according to probate rules or the decedent’s will. For families in Atherton, combining a survival action with a wrongful death claim can ensure both the decedent’s own losses and the family’s economic and non-economic harms are addressed in a single legal proceeding.
The statute of limitations sets the deadline for filing a wrongful death lawsuit in California, typically within two years from the date of death, though exceptions and variations may apply in specific circumstances. Missing this deadline can bar a claim, so Atherton families should act promptly to preserve their rights. Timely consultation, evidence collection, and filing help ensure claims proceed without procedural obstacles. Certain cases involving government entities or delayed discovery may have different deadlines, making local legal guidance important to determine the applicable timeframe for filing.
When pursuing a wrongful death claim, families may weigh a limited approach that focuses narrowly on immediate damages against a comprehensive strategy that documents long-term losses, future support, and broader non-economic harms. A limited approach might seek only funeral and medical expenses for a quick resolution, while a comprehensive approach aims to capture full economic and non-economic impacts, including projected future earnings and loss of companionship. For Atherton residents, local cost-of-living and family circumstances affect these choices, and evaluating both paths helps ensure families select the approach that best matches their needs and goals for compensation and closure.
A limited wrongful death claim can be appropriate if a family’s primary goal is to secure quick reimbursement for immediate out-of-pocket expenses, such as final medical bills and funeral costs. This option may apply when future income loss is minimal or when claimants prefer a faster resolution to address urgent financial obligations. In Atherton, where families may face significant short-term expenses after a death, focusing on those immediate needs can provide timely relief. However, this approach may forgo compensation for longer-term losses, so careful consideration and consultation are advised before choosing this path.
A limited approach may also suit cases where liability is clear and the anticipated long-term financial impact is modest, such as when the deceased had limited future earning capacity or no dependents. Settling for immediate, defined losses can reduce litigation costs and speed resolution. For Atherton families, analyzing the deceased’s age, employment status, and household contributions helps determine whether a narrow claim is sufficient. Even when liability is straightforward, families should weigh potential future consequences and consult to ensure that important long-term damages are not overlooked in the interest of expediency.
A comprehensive approach is often necessary when the deceased provided substantial financial support or had significant future earning potential. In such cases, properly valuing future lost income and benefits requires expert analysis and documentation. For Atherton families, where household budgets and future planning may hinge on the decedent’s contributions, capturing these long-term losses ensures survivors receive appropriate compensation to maintain financial stability. A thorough claim collects employment records, tax returns, and vocational assessments to present a clear picture of the economic impact on beneficiaries over time.
Complex cases involving severe non-economic harm, multiple defendants, or disputed liability benefit from a comprehensive approach that addresses all facets of loss. Presenting claims for loss of companionship, emotional suffering, and diminished life quality often requires detailed narratives, witness testimony, and sometimes expert input. In Atherton, where incidents can involve multiple parties or institutions, a broad claim strategy helps ensure every responsible party is identified and held accountable. Comprehensive preparation also improves negotiating leverage and the potential for a fair settlement that reflects the totality of the family’s losses.
Pursuing a comprehensive wrongful death claim can result in compensation that more fully addresses both the financial and emotional impacts of a loss. By documenting past and future economic harm along with non-economic damages, families increase the likelihood of a settlement or judgment that covers a wide range of needs. For Atherton residents, where costs associated with medical care and funerals can be high, thorough valuation of losses helps protect family financial security. A broad approach also sends a clear message of the seriousness of the claim, often encouraging more meaningful settlement offers from insurers or defendants.
Comprehensive claims typically involve careful evidence gathering, including medical records, expert reports, and detailed financial documentation. This thorough preparation can strengthen negotiation positions and provide clarity in court proceedings if the matter goes to trial. For families in Atherton, such diligence helps ensure all contributors to a household’s welfare are considered and that intangible losses like loss of guidance and companionship are fully presented. While the process may take longer than a limited approach, the potential for fairer, more complete compensation often justifies the investment of time and resources.
A comprehensive approach allows for a precise calculation of future economic losses, including lost earnings, benefits, and household contributions. This requires assembling income records, employment history, and expert projections about career trajectories and inflation. For Atherton families, capturing the full scope of financial impact is important to maintain stability after a loved one’s death. Accurate valuation ensures settlements reflect realistic future needs rather than just immediate costs, and it supports informed decisions about settlement offers versus continued litigation when necessary to achieve fair compensation.
Thorough preparation and clear documentation of damages strengthen a family’s position during settlement talks and in court. When insurers see a complete record of medical evidence, financial loss, and personal testimony, they are likelier to make reasonable offers. For Atherton claimants, presenting a compelling, well-supported case demonstrates seriousness and readiness to pursue full relief. This attention to detail can shorten negotiations and reduce the likelihood of undervalued settlements, ultimately helping families secure compensation that better reflects their true losses and future needs.
After a fatal incident, gather and preserve all relevant records promptly, including medical bills, hospital notes, police reports, and photographs of the scene. For families in Atherton, obtaining timely documentation from local hospitals, first responders, and law enforcement preserves key facts that support liability and damages. Keep a secure folder with copies of financial records such as pay stubs, tax returns, and receipts for funeral expenses. Early preservation prevents loss of critical evidence and helps establish a clear timeline and pattern of harm when building a case for compensation.
Document the emotional and personal effects of the loss by keeping journals, collecting statements from family members, and recording the ways daily life and household dynamics have changed. Although non-economic damages are harder to quantify, detailed descriptions of loss of companionship, guidance, and emotional suffering provide persuasive context for negotiations and court proceedings. For Atherton families, preserving these narratives alongside financial records helps ensure claims reflect both tangible and intangible harms, contributing to a more complete and compelling presentation of the family’s needs.
Filing a wrongful death claim can provide financial relief for immediate expenses and longer-term support for surviving family members. It allows relatives to seek compensation for medical bills, funeral costs, lost income, and the emotional toll of losing a loved one. Pursuing a claim also encourages accountability for those whose negligence or misconduct led to the death, potentially preventing similar incidents in the community. For Atherton residents, where local resources and family expectations may create unique needs, a successful claim helps secure funds necessary to address ongoing household and care obligations.
Beyond financial relief, the legal process creates a documented record of responsibility that can be important for families seeking closure. Compensation can support children’s education, replace lost household support, and cover counseling or therapy for survivors. Engaging early with a law firm helps families navigate procedural requirements, preserve evidence, and evaluate settlement options. For those in Atherton, careful planning and holistic consideration of both economic and emotional harms help families determine whether pursuing a claim aligns with their long-term recovery and financial planning goals.
Wrongful death claims commonly arise from motor vehicle collisions, medical malpractice, dangerous property conditions, workplace incidents, and defective products. In the Atherton area, traffic-related fatalities and healthcare-related deaths are among the typical scenarios prompting civil claims. Each circumstance requires tailored investigation to identify liable parties, such as negligent drivers, municipalities responsible for road maintenance, medical providers, or manufacturers. Understanding the specific facts and applicable legal standards in each type of case helps families pursue appropriate remedies and develop a strategy to prove liability and damages.
Many wrongful death cases stem from vehicle collisions involving cars, motorcycles, or pedestrians. These incidents often produce clear physical evidence, witness accounts, and official traffic reports, but liability can still be contested. For Atherton residents, roadways and commuter routes can present hazards that contribute to serious accidents. Prompt collection of police reports, traffic camera footage, and witness statements helps establish the sequence of events. Gathering medical records related to the decedent’s injuries before death also supports claims for both economic and non-economic damages.
When medical care falls below accepted standards and leads to a patient’s death, families may pursue wrongful death claims against healthcare providers or institutions. These cases can be complex, requiring review of medical records, expert medical opinions, and an understanding of standards of care. For Atherton families, promptly obtaining complete medical documentation and consulting professionals who can review treatment decisions is essential. Such cases often involve careful analysis of causation to show that the provider’s actions directly contributed to the fatal outcome and the damages claimed by survivors.
Wrongful deaths can also result from unsafe property conditions or defective products that create unreasonable risks. Property owners and manufacturers have responsibilities to maintain safe conditions and design products that do not pose undue hazards. In Atherton, incidents involving falls, pool accidents, or malfunctioning equipment can lead to claims against property owners or manufacturers. Investigations typically involve site inspections, maintenance records, and expert analysis to show how a dangerous condition or defect contributed to the fatal incident and who bears legal responsibility for the resulting losses.
Law Republic APC provides compassionate representation to families in Atherton navigating the complexities of wrongful death claims. We aim to reduce administrative burdens by managing evidence collection, communication with insurers and opposing parties, and filing necessary legal documents. By offering clear guidance on timelines, settlement options, and courtroom procedures, we help families make informed choices that reflect their priorities. Our goal is to secure fair compensation while allowing survivors to focus on healing and rebuilding, taking care to address both practical financial needs and the personal impacts of their loss.
Law Republic APC understands the sensitive nature of wrongful death claims and approaches each matter with careful attention to detail and client communication. For Atherton residents, we prioritize building a clear factual record, preserving evidence, and pursuing compensation for both economic and non-economic losses. We tailor strategies to each family’s circumstances, working to identify responsible parties and to present damages accurately and persuasively. Our team focuses on practical solutions that align with client goals, whether that means negotiating a fair settlement or preparing a case for trial if necessary.
Clients can expect timely updates, candid assessments of case strengths and risks, and proactive handling of procedural requirements. We coordinate investigations, obtain necessary records, and consult with professionals to quantify damages so families can make informed decisions. For Atherton families coping with grief, this level of coordination can relieve stress and streamline the legal process. Our approach emphasizes respect for family priorities while diligently pursuing compensation that addresses both immediate needs and future financial security.
We also recognize the local context of Atherton and San Mateo County courts, which can influence scheduling and procedural matters. Our familiarity with regional practices helps in anticipating timelines and arranging timely filings. From initial consultation through case resolution, we aim to provide responsive support and a clear roadmap for moving forward. Families receive tailored attention to ensure their legal options and potential outcomes are communicated in plain language, helping them make decisions that reflect their values and long-term needs.
Our process begins with a thorough case intake to understand the circumstances, identify potential defendants, and gather available evidence. We then investigate medical records, accident reports, and witness statements, while preserving key documentation. After a careful review, we advise on likely damages and legal options, including settlement versus litigation. Throughout, we maintain clear communication about strategy and timelines. For Atherton families, this structured approach helps manage expectations and ensures all relevant damages are pursued alongside efforts to minimize disruption during a difficult time.
The first step focuses on gathering information and preserving evidence that supports liability and damages. This includes collecting medical records, police reports, employment documents, and any available video or photographic evidence. We interview witnesses and work to secure statements while memories are fresh. For Atherton incidents, prompt action can be especially important due to local traffic patterns and potential loss of evidence. This early preservation lays the groundwork for accurate case valuation and positions families to respond effectively to insurance inquiries or opposing counsel.
During the initial consultation, we discuss the facts, identify potential damages, and outline next steps for documentation. We request and begin collecting medical and official records, and advise families on how to preserve personal evidence. This stage also includes reviewing any immediate financial needs and advising on securing bills and receipts. For Atherton clients, we ensure local details are considered, such as where incidents occurred and which local agencies may hold relevant reports. Clear instructions during this phase help protect legal rights and keep the process moving forward efficiently.
We proactively locate and preserve witness testimony and physical evidence, including photographs, damaged property, and surveillance footage when available. Timely efforts to document the scene and secure corroborating evidence are essential to building a persuasive case. For Atherton cases, we may coordinate site inspections, request records from local agencies, and work with investigators to reconstruct events. Preserving this evidence early minimizes the risk of loss or alteration and strengthens the factual foundation needed to prove liability and support claims for full compensation.
With evidence collected, we quantify damages and build a comprehensive case file for negotiation or litigation. This includes expert reports when necessary, valuation of economic losses, and detailed narratives for non-economic harms. We present demand packages to insurers and opposing parties and attempt to resolve the matter through negotiation or mediation. For Atherton families, clear presentation of both tangible and intangible losses often improves settlement prospects. If negotiations do not yield a fair outcome, we prepare for litigation by refining arguments and readying necessary witnesses and documentation for trial.
Calculating damages involves compiling income records, medical expenses, and crafting projections for future losses. Where appropriate, we obtain opinions from vocational, medical, or economic professionals to support future earning capacity and cost projections. These analyses strengthen demands by showing concrete financial impacts. For Atherton claims, local economic factors and family circumstances are incorporated to ensure damage calculations reflect real needs. Professional support helps translate complex financial and medical data into clear evidence that decision makers can readily evaluate during settlement talks or trial.
We engage with insurers and defense counsel to seek fair compensation through negotiation and, when helpful, mediation. Presenting a well-supported demand package that includes documentation and expert reports increases the likelihood of a meaningful offer. For families in Atherton, mediation can be a cost-effective alternative to trial, providing a structured opportunity to reach agreement with the assistance of a neutral mediator. We always evaluate offers in light of the case’s strengths and the family’s priorities, advising on whether a proposed settlement meets long-term needs and objectives.
If settlement efforts do not produce fair compensation, we prepare the case for litigation, which includes drafting pleadings, conducting discovery, and preparing witnesses for testimony. Trial preparation involves organizing evidence, refining legal arguments, and rehearsing presentations to the court. For families in Atherton, being prepared for trial can also encourage better settlement offers by demonstrating readiness to pursue full relief. Throughout litigation, we keep clients informed about timelines, risks, and costs so they can make well-informed decisions about whether to proceed to trial or continue negotiating.
Discovery enables both sides to obtain documents, witness statements, and expert reports that support their claims. We manage document production, take and defend depositions, and prepare witnesses to testify clearly and confidently. Proper discovery helps identify weaknesses in the opposing case and reinforces the evidence supporting damages. For Atherton families, thorough preparation during discovery is vital to ensure testimony accurately reflects the impact of the loss and that all relevant documentation is available to present a persuasive case at trial or during settlement discussions.
At trial, the case is presented to a judge or jury with opening statements, witness testimony, and evidence admission, followed by closing arguments. Effective presentation requires clear organization and credible witnesses who can speak to liability and damages. Our trial preparation focuses on telling the family’s story in a compelling way while adhering to procedural rules. For Atherton claimants, the goal is to obtain a judgment that fairly compensates for losses. Even when trials are lengthy, thorough preparation often encourages negotiated resolutions before final verdicts are reached.
In California, wrongful death claims are generally brought by the decedent’s spouse, domestic partner, children, and sometimes other dependents. If no eligible survivors exist, the decedent’s estate or personal representative may pursue a claim on behalf of the deceased. The law specifies who has standing to sue, so it is important to identify proper claimants early in the process to ensure the case is filed by those entitled to recovery. Acting promptly helps preserve rights and meet procedural requirements. Families in Atherton should gather basic documentation and consult counsel to determine who may bring a claim and how to proceed. Early guidance also clarifies whether multiple claimants should participate or if an estate representative should lead the action for consistency and proper distribution of any recovery.
Wrongful death actions can include economic damages such as medical and funeral expenses, lost wages, and the loss of financial support that the deceased would have provided. These damages are supported by records like bills, tax returns, and employment documents that help quantify past and projected losses. Accurate documentation is key to establishing the financial impact on survivors. Non-economic damages are also recoverable and aim to address the emotional and relational impact of the loss, such as loss of companionship, care, and guidance. While these harms lack precise monetary metrics, thoughtful presentation of personal narratives, witness statements, and comparative case examples aids in demonstrating their significance during settlement or trial, particularly for families based in Atherton pursuing a full measure of relief.
The statute of limitations for wrongful death lawsuits in California is typically two years from the date of death, though exceptions can apply in special situations. Missing the filing deadline may bar recovery, so it is imperative to act quickly. Timely consultation helps identify any exceptions or unique circumstances that could extend or alter the filing period. For Atherton residents, local court procedures and possible involvement of government entities can affect deadlines, so obtaining legal advice early ensures filings occur within required timeframes. Prompt action also improves evidence preservation and increases the likelihood of successfully pursuing full compensation for the family.
Key evidence in wrongful death cases includes medical records, autopsy and toxicology reports, police or incident reports, witness statements, photographs or video, and financial documentation showing economic losses. These items help prove liability, causation, and the scope of damages. Gathering such evidence quickly is essential, as records can be altered or lost over time. For cases in Atherton, local sources such as hospital records, traffic camera footage, and neighborhood witness accounts can be particularly valuable. Effective legal preparation focuses on systematically collecting and preserving these materials to support claims during settlement negotiations or trial.
Yes. Civil wrongful death claims are separate from criminal prosecutions and can proceed regardless of whether criminal charges are filed. The civil standard of proof is lower than the criminal standard, so a lack of criminal conviction does not prevent a successful civil claim. Families can pursue compensation even if the criminal case is ongoing, although coordination may be needed to avoid interfering with criminal proceedings. For Atherton families, pursuing a civil claim can provide another route to accountability and financial relief while not depending on the outcome of any criminal case. Legal counsel can advise on timing and potential impacts, ensuring that civil actions proceed in a manner that respects related criminal matters when necessary.
The time to resolve a wrongful death claim varies based on factors such as case complexity, number of defendants, need for expert opinions, and whether the case settles or goes to trial. Some matters resolve through negotiation in several months, while others may take a year or more if litigation proves necessary. Prompt evidence gathering and clear documentation can shorten timelines by facilitating settlement talks. For Atherton residents, local court schedules and the complexity of medical or accident reconstruction issues may influence duration. Families should prepare for a process that may require patience, and counsel can provide tailored timeline estimates and strategies to pursue timely and fair resolutions.
Many wrongful death cases settle before trial through negotiation or mediation, which can be less disruptive and more predictable than litigation. However, if settlement discussions do not yield fair compensation, going to trial may be necessary to pursue full recovery. Preparing for trial also signals to insurers and opponents that the claim will be pursued diligently if needed, which can encourage reasonable offers during settlement talks. For families in Atherton, the decision to try a case rests on the strength of evidence, potential recovery, and client goals. Counsel will advise on the likelihood of settlement versus trial and prepare the case so clients can choose the option that best aligns with their needs and expectations.
When multiple parties contributed to the death, plaintiffs may pursue claims against all potentially liable entities to recover full compensation. California law allows apportionment of fault among defendants, which can affect the amount each party pays. Identifying every responsible party is important for maximizing recovery, and careful investigation can reveal corporate, municipal, or individual contributors to the incident. In Atherton cases involving multiple defendants, coordinating claims and negotiating with several insurers may be complex. Legal counsel helps manage these interactions, ensuring evidence supports claims against each responsible party and seeking contributions from all sources to address the family’s full losses.
Non-economic damages like loss of companionship are evaluated by considering the relationship between the deceased and survivors, the extent of emotional suffering, and comparisons to similar cases. Courts and insurers look for coherent narratives, testimony about the deceased’s role in family life, and supporting documentation that illustrates how the loss affects daily life and emotional well-being. Such evidence helps translate intangible harms into a persuasive claim for compensation. For Atherton families, gathering statements from family members, friends, and community figures, along with records of the deceased’s involvement in household and community life, strengthens claims for non-economic damages. A comprehensive presentation helps decision makers understand the depth and breadth of the loss being claimed.
Families in Atherton can start by gathering immediate documentation such as medical and police reports, receipts for funeral expenses, and financial records of the deceased. Reaching out to local hospitals, law enforcement, and any available witnesses helps preserve crucial evidence. Initial consultations with counsel can clarify standing, likely damages, and procedural steps to begin a claim. Contacting a law firm for a prompt case review enables early preservation of evidence and timely filing. Legal counsel can advise on next steps, help obtain necessary records, and explain the options for pursuing compensation and managing communications with insurers or opposing parties.
"*" indicates required fields