If you bought or leased an RV or motorhome and it has persistent defects that impair safety, use, or value, California’s Lemon Law may provide remedies. Residents of Santa Paula, Ventura County often face issues with new and used recreational vehicles including repeated mechanical failures, electrical problems, or defects that the manufacturer cannot repair after reasonable opportunities. Law Republic APC helps vehicle owners understand their rights under California law and pursue buybacks, replacements, or monetary damages. If your RV troubles interfere with travel plans, safety, or enjoyment, you deserve straightforward information about options available locally in Santa Paula and how to begin a claim.
Many RV owners in Santa Paula do not realize that persistent defects can qualify a vehicle as a lemon under state law, even when problems appear intermittently. The key is whether the manufacturer or dealer had a reasonable opportunity to repair the defect and whether the problem substantially impairs the vehicle’s use, value, or safety. RVs and motorhomes have unique systems—plumbing, electrical, slide-outs, appliances—that can pose complex legal and technical issues. Our approach is to explain the legal framework in clear language, help gather repair records, and evaluate whether a claim for repurchase, replacement, or compensation is appropriate for your situation.
Pursuing an RV lemon law claim can restore financial fairness when repeated defects make your recreational vehicle unreliable or unsafe. In Santa Paula, owners pay for vehicles that should offer dependable travel and comfort; unresolved defects can cause ongoing repair expenses, lost use, and safety concerns. A successful claim may result in a refund, replacement, or monetary compensation and may shift repair costs back to the manufacturer. Beyond compensation, asserting your legal rights can encourage manufacturers to address systemic issues. Seeking guidance early helps preserve records and strengthens your position when negotiating with manufacturers or pursuing formal remedies under California law.
Law Republic APC serves clients across Ventura County, including Santa Paula, focusing on vehicle defect and consumer protection matters. Our team guides clients through documentation, repair history review, and communication with manufacturers or dealers. We prioritize clear communication and practical strategies to help clients explore repurchase, replacement, or monetary remedies under California’s protections for defective vehicles. When representing RV owners, we coordinate technical assessments, preserve warranty and repair records, and advocate for fair resolutions while keeping clients informed about likely timelines and potential outcomes specific to recreational vehicles and motorhomes.
California’s Lemon Law provides protection when a new or certain used vehicle has substantial defects that the manufacturer cannot fix after a reasonable number of attempts. For RVs and motorhomes, this can include failures in propulsion, braking, electrical systems, slide mechanisms, and other components essential to safe operation or basic use. The law looks at repair attempts, warranty coverage, and how much the defect interferes with the vehicle’s intended function. In Santa Paula, documenting every repair visit, part replacement, and communication with the dealer or manufacturer is essential to building a strong claim under the statute.
Because recreational vehicles have integrated living systems, proving a substantial impairment may involve technical evidence and repair records from specialized service centers. RV owners in Santa Paula should maintain a clear timeline of issues, repair orders, and warranty work. The lemon law process often begins with an evaluation of whether the number and nature of repair attempts meet California’s standards for a reasonable opportunity to fix defects. Understanding how warranty terms and repair history interact with statutory protections helps owners decide whether to pursue a claim or negotiate directly with a manufacturer.
Under California law, an RV or motorhome may be considered a lemon when it has a defect that substantially impairs its use, value, or safety and the manufacturer has been given a reasonable chance to repair the problem without success. This definition applies to many major systems in an RV, including powertrain, electrical, HVAC, plumbing, and slide-out mechanisms. For Santa Paula owners, the practical question is whether documented repair attempts show the manufacturer failed to correct the defect. Evidence, such as repeated repair orders and persistent failures, supports a claim that the vehicle meets the legal definition of a lemon.
The lemon law process for RVs involves gathering proof of defects, compiling repair records, and demonstrating the manufacturer was given reasonable opportunities to fix the problem. Important elements include the warranty status, number and type of repair attempts, whether the defect affects safety or use, and timelines of repairs. In many cases, negotiation followed by formal demand letters leads to buyback or replacement discussions. If negotiations fail, formal claims or litigation may be necessary. For Santa Paula RV owners, early documentation and timely communication with service centers are critical to preserving legal options.
This glossary explains terms commonly used in RV lemon law matters so Santa Paula owners can read documents and repair histories with confidence. Definitions include warranty coverage, reasonable repair attempts, substantial impairment, manufacturer’s repurchase obligation, and reimbursement for incidental costs. Familiarity with these terms helps owners assess whether problems qualify under California law and what remedies may be available. Keeping clear records of service visits, parts replaced, and written communications with dealers or manufacturers strengthens a claim and makes the inquiry process more efficient.
Warranty coverage refers to the manufacturer’s written obligations to repair or replace defective parts within a specified timeframe or mileage. For RVs, warranty terms may cover the chassis, powertrain, appliances, and integrated systems differently. Understanding what is and is not covered under the RV’s warranty is essential for Santa Paula owners when determining who is responsible for repairs and whether those repairs should lead to a lemon law claim. Keeping copies of the warranty booklet and any extended warranty documents helps clarify responsibilities and timelines for asserting legal rights.
Substantial impairment means the defect significantly reduces the vehicle’s use, value, or safety. In a motorhome, a defective electrical system that prevents reliable operation of appliances or a brake issue that threatens safety would likely be considered substantial. For Santa Paula owners, the question is whether the defect meaningfully interferes with normal operation or with the vehicle’s intended recreational use. Documentation that shows repeated failures and safety concerns supports a finding of substantial impairment under California law.
Reasonable repair attempts are the number and scope of service visits a manufacturer must be given to attempt correction of a defect. California law does not set a fixed number for every situation; instead, it considers the severity of the defect, the history of repairs, and whether the issue persists despite efforts. For Santa Paula RV owners, keeping detailed records of every service appointment, the work performed, parts replaced, and the duration of downtime helps establish whether the manufacturer had a sufficient opportunity to fix the problem.
Manufacturer remedies under the lemon law can include repurchasing the defective vehicle, providing a replacement, or offering monetary compensation for repairs and diminished value. Remedies may also cover reasonable incidental expenses like towing or repair-related transportation when documented. For Santa Paula residents, remedy negotiations typically follow a demand letter or claim submission and may involve arbitration or litigation if the manufacturer does not agree to a fair resolution. Clear repair records and evidence of the defect’s impact improve the likelihood of obtaining appropriate relief.
RV owners in Santa Paula can pursue several pathways when facing persistent defects: negotiate directly with the dealer or manufacturer, pursue lemon law remedies, seek arbitration if provided by warranty terms, or file a civil claim for breach of warranty and related damages. Each option has advantages and trade-offs related to time, cost, and potential recovery. Direct negotiation may be faster but yield limited results, while formal lemon law claims can secure repurchase or replacement. Assessing the situation with repair documentation and warranty terms helps determine the most effective route for each owner.
A limited approach may be appropriate when an RV problem is minor, isolated, and fully resolved after a single repair visit without recurrence. For Santa Paula owners, issues that are covered by warranty and fixed quickly with no ongoing impact on safety or use often do not warrant formal lemon law action. In such situations, keeping clear repair records and monitoring the vehicle for recurrence is sensible. If the issue returns or additional defects emerge, the owner should re-evaluate whether a broader legal remedy is needed under California law.
When warranty-covered issues are addressed promptly and the manufacturer honors repair obligations within reasonable timeframes, a limited approach focused on repairs and follow-up may be sufficient. Santa Paula owners should ensure repairs are documented and that warranty service is provided at authorized facilities. If the warranty process resolves the problem and no substantial impairment remains, pursuing formal claims may be unnecessary. However, continued vigilance and careful record-keeping remain important in case further issues arise that change the assessment.
A comprehensive legal approach is often necessary when an RV experiences repeated failures that persist after multiple documented repair attempts. For many Santa Paula owners, persistent defects in critical systems—such as propulsion, braking, electrical, or structural components—can render the vehicle unreliable or unsafe. When the manufacturer has not remedied the problem despite repeated opportunities, pursuing lemon law remedies, gathering expert technical evaluations, and considering formal claims helps protect owners’ rights and pursue remedies like repurchase or replacement under California law.
RVs and motorhomes include complex integrated systems that can require expensive and time-consuming repairs. When repair costs mount or the vehicle spends excessive time out of service, a comprehensive legal approach can address the economic impact and seek recovery for loss of use, repair expenses, and diminished value. Santa Paula owners facing prolonged mechanical or system failures benefit from a structured evaluation of warranty obligations, repair history, and possible remedies under California’s consumer protection laws to pursue fair compensation.
A comprehensive approach brings organization and thorough documentation to a lemon law claim, improving chances of a favorable resolution. For Santa Paula RV owners, compiling repair histories, correspondence, and expert assessments clarifies the nature and persistence of defects and helps frame negotiations with manufacturers. This approach can streamline demands for repurchase, replacement, or monetary relief and may reduce the time an RV remains unreliable. Comprehensive preparation also supports potential arbitration or litigation, ensuring the owner’s position is clearly presented and supported by evidence.
Beyond improving case presentation, a comprehensive strategy helps owners quantify losses and identify all available remedies, including reimbursement for documented incidental expenses like towing and alternate transportation. In Santa Paula, where RV travel is valued, reclaiming fair value for a defective vehicle restores financial protection. A structured process also helps manage communications with manufacturers to avoid misunderstandings and ensures repair credits, buyback figures, or replacement offers account for the vehicle’s full condition and the owner’s documented experience.
A thorough compilation of repair records, warranty documents, and correspondence strengthens the owner’s negotiation position with manufacturers. In Santa Paula claims, presenting a clear timeline and evidence of repeated failures helps demonstrate the extent of the problem and the manufacturer’s failure to resolve it. This clarity often encourages manufacturers to offer a fair settlement rather than face formal claims. Well-documented cases also reduce misunderstandings and accelerate resolution, helping owners move on from prolonged repairs and regain reliable use of their recreational vehicle.
By pursuing a comprehensive strategy, owners are better positioned to obtain the full range of remedies the law allows, including repurchase, replacement, or monetary recovery. For Santa Paula residents, asserting rights under California’s protections can recover repair costs, diminished value, and documented incidental expenses. Comprehensive preparation helps ensure that potential settlements reflect the vehicle’s true condition and the owner’s losses. It also provides a clear record should arbitration or court proceedings be required to secure a fair outcome.
Keep a detailed log of every service appointment, including dates, odometer or hour meter readings, work performed, parts replaced, and written repair orders. For Santa Paula RV owners, consistent documentation creates a persuasive timeline that shows repeated attempts to fix the problem. Photographs of defects, receipts for towing or rental vehicles, and records of communication with the dealer or manufacturer add supporting evidence. Organized records make it easier to evaluate whether your vehicle meets the conditions for a lemon law claim and streamline discussions with the manufacturer or legal representatives.
Start documenting issues and communicating with the dealer or manufacturer as soon as defects arise, and preserve all records in a secure place. Prompt action helps prevent gaps in the repair history and strengthens your position if you later pursue a lemon law claim. Santa Paula owners should collect warranty papers, repair orders, photos, and correspondence, and summarize events in a single timeline. Early preservation of records and continued vigilance about recurring problems make it simpler to demonstrate persistent defects and the impact on vehicle use and safety.
Owners should consider professional guidance when defects persist despite multiple repair attempts, when safety is affected, or when repair downtime is frequent and costly. For Santa Paula RV owners, the time an RV spends out of service can erode enjoyment and lead to additional expenses. Assistance helps evaluate whether the repair history and warranty coverage support lemon law remedies. Proper assessment can clarify likely outcomes, outline necessary documentation, and guide negotiations with manufacturers, improving the likelihood of repurchase, replacement, or compensation for documented losses.
Another reason to consider assistance is to ensure incidental costs and lost use are included in a claim if appropriate. RV repairs can create secondary expenses such as towing, rental vehicles, or canceled trips. In Santa Paula, where RV travel is valued, recovering these documented costs may be part of a fair resolution. Professional guidance helps frame demands to include such losses and ensures the owner’s full experience and financial impact are presented in discussions with manufacturers or in formal claims under California consumer protection laws.
Frequent or unresolved mechanical failures, recurring electrical malfunctions, slide-out or structural defects, and persistent appliance or plumbing issues are common reasons owners seek legal remedies. When these issues reappear after multiple repair attempts or seriously limit the vehicle’s use, owners often pursue lemon law protections. Additionally, when repairs are denied or warranty coverage is disputed, documenting problems and seeking assistance becomes important. Santa Paula owners facing prolonged repair timelines or escalating costs benefit from evaluating legal options to recover value or secure a replacement.
Recurring engine, transmission, or drivetrain problems that continue despite multiple repair attempts can leave an RV unreliable and unsafe. For Santa Paula residents, repeated trips to the shop and ongoing repair bills are strong indicators that the vehicle may qualify for lemon law remedies. Thorough documentation of each failure and repair is essential to show the repeated nature of the problem and the manufacturer’s inability to resolve it within a reasonable timeframe under California law.
Electrical failures and defective appliances can undermine the livability and safety of an RV, especially when they recur after repairs. Issues like unreliable power systems, faulty wiring, or failing onboard appliances reduce the vehicle’s value and usability. Santa Paula owners should log each repair attempt and any service recommendations. When repeated repairs fail to restore proper functioning, these conditions often justify pursuing remedies available under California’s protections for defective vehicles.
Problems with slide-outs, seals, or structural components can compromise both convenience and safety. For motorhome owners in Santa Paula, persistent alignment issues, leaks, or mechanical failures of slide systems are particularly disruptive. Documenting repair dates, parts replaced, and ongoing performance concerns helps build a record showing the defect’s persistence. Such evidence supports claims that the vehicle’s use and value are substantially impaired, which may lead to manufacturer remedies under state law.
Law Republic APC provides guidance to Santa Paula residents dealing with RV or motorhome defects. We help assess repair histories, warranty coverage, and whether a lemon law claim is appropriate based on the documented facts. Our team explains options for negotiating with manufacturers, pursuing arbitration if required, or filing formal claims to seek repurchase, replacement, or monetary recovery. If your RV has been repeatedly out of service or presents ongoing safety concerns, we can help you gather the necessary records and present a clear case for fair remedies under California law.
Law Republic APC focuses on achieving practical results for vehicle owners by organizing repair histories, preserving evidence, and communicating clearly about likely outcomes. Santa Paula clients receive guidance on documenting repairs and preparing demand letters to manufacturers. Our approach emphasizes timely action and careful evidence-gathering to support claims for repurchase, replacement, or monetary relief under California law. We keep clients informed about realistic timelines and expected steps so they can make confident decisions based on the facts of their case.
We assist clients in reviewing warranty terms and coordinating technical assessments when necessary to clarify the nature and persistence of defects. For Santa Paula RV owners, this often involves compiling service invoices, correspondence with dealers, and any third-party repair documentation. Presenting a clear, organized case improves the prospects of negotiation and settlement and facilitates efficient resolution if arbitration or litigation becomes necessary. Our goal is to help clients secure fair outcomes while minimizing unnecessary delays and expenses.
Throughout the process we prioritize open communication and documentation so that owners understand the strengths and limits of their claims under California’s protections for defective vehicles. For Santa Paula residents, pursuing a lemon law remedy can restore value and address repeated reliability or safety problems. We work to make the process manageable by handling communications, organizing records, and advocating for fair solutions tailored to each owner’s circumstances and documented losses.
Our process begins with a thorough review of repair records, warranty documents, and the owner’s account of defects and repair attempts. For Santa Paula clients we explain legal standards that define reasonable repair opportunities and substantial impairment. After evaluating documentation, we advise whether to pursue negotiation, demand letters, arbitration, or formal claims. We then compile a clear case file, communicate with the manufacturer, and seek to resolve the matter efficiently, while preparing for arbitration or litigation if necessary to protect the owner’s rights under California law.
The first step is a comprehensive review of your repair history, warranty information, and related communications to determine if your RV meets the criteria for a lemon law claim. For Santa Paula owners, this includes collecting invoices, work orders, and any photographs or records showing persistent defects. Establishing a timeline of repair attempts and the impact on vehicle use helps assess whether the manufacturer had reasonable opportunities to cure the problem and whether pursuing a formal remedy is appropriate under California law.
Gather all service orders, receipts, and warranty repair documentation from dealers and authorized service centers. For Santa Paula owners, having complete records of every visit, the work performed, and parts replaced creates a persuasive history that shows repeated repair attempts. Photographs of defects and notes about when problems occurred are also helpful. Organized documentation forms the backbone of any lemon law claim and is critical to demonstrating the persistence and severity of defects under California law.
Carefully review warranty terms, purchase contracts, and any extended coverage to determine what repairs should be covered and what dispute resolution provisions apply. For Santa Paula residents, understanding whether arbitration is required or if specific notice procedures must be followed helps shape the next steps. Identifying covered components and applicable timelines clarifies the manufacturer’s obligations and informs whether direct negotiation or formal claims are the best path to recovery under California consumer protection statutes.
Once documentation is compiled, the next step is to present a formal demand to the manufacturer outlining the repair history and requested remedies. For Santa Paula owners, a clear demand letter may lead to buyback, replacement, or settlement discussions. The negotiation phase seeks to resolve the matter without formal proceedings, though we prepare for arbitration or litigation if necessary. Effective negotiation relies on credible evidence, a realistic assessment of damages, and clear presentation of the defects’ impact on use and safety.
The demand letter summarizes the repair timeline, warranty coverage, and the relief requested—such as repurchase, replacement, or monetary compensation. For Santa Paula owners, a well-drafted demand highlights repeated failed repairs, documented expenses, and the vehicle’s diminished use or value. Clear documentation and a professional presentation encourage manufacturers to address the claim seriously and may lead to expedited settlement offers without the need for arbitration or court proceedings.
Negotiations involve back-and-forth discussions with the manufacturer to reach a fair resolution. For Santa Paula clients, this stage can resolve the claim through a repurchase, replacement vehicle, or monetary payment that accounts for repairs and inconvenience. If a settlement cannot be reached, the next steps include arbitration or filing a formal claim. Maintaining clear records and realistic expectations helps owners evaluate offers and decide whether to accept a settlement or pursue further action under California law.
If negotiation fails, the final steps may include arbitration under warranty terms or filing a lawsuit to pursue remedies available under California’s lemon law. For Santa Paula owners, arbitration can be faster and less costly, but the specifics of warranty agreements influence whether it is required. Litigation may be necessary when arbitration is not available or when a more robust remedy is needed. Preparing for these paths requires a complete evidentiary record, witness statements, technical assessments, and clear documentation of damages.
When arbitration is mandated by the warranty, we prepare a clear submission that organizes repair records, correspondence, and any technical evaluations. For Santa Paula owners, presenting precise timelines and documented expenses supports a compelling arbitration claim. We assist in gathering witness statements, repair invoices, and expert opinions when needed to explain the defect’s impact. Thorough preparation can improve the likelihood of a favorable arbitration outcome without the delay and expense of litigation.
If arbitration is not required or fails to produce fair results, pursuing litigation may be the next step to secure full remedies under California law. For Santa Paula residents, litigation involves filing a complaint, discovery, and potential trial or settlement. Thorough documentation, expert testimony, and persuasive presentation of the repair history and damages are essential. Litigation can secure repurchase or replacement and recovery for repair costs and other documented losses when negotiated settlements are insufficient.
An RV or motorhome may qualify as a lemon when it has a substantial defect that impairs its use, value, or safety and the manufacturer has been given reasonable opportunities to repair the problem. For Santa Paula owners, relevant defects can include recurring propulsion issues, braking problems, persistent electrical failures, slide-out malfunctions, or other defects that significantly interfere with normal operation or living functions of the vehicle. The legal analysis focuses on the nature of the defect and the repair history. Documenting repair visits, work performed, and communications with the dealer or manufacturer is essential. This evidence shows whether the manufacturer had a reasonable chance to repair the problem and whether the defect continues to substantially impair the vehicle’s use. Clear records improve the likelihood of a favorable resolution, whether by negotiation, arbitration, or formal claim under California law.
California law does not prescribe a fixed number of repair attempts for every case; rather, it evaluates whether the manufacturer had a reasonable number of opportunities to fix the defect. The seriousness of the defect, the type of failure, and the length of repair-related downtime all influence what constitutes a reasonable number of attempts. For Santa Paula RV owners, repeated repair visits for the same substantive issue strengthen a claim that the manufacturer failed to cure the defect within a reasonable time. Maintaining thorough documentation of each service visit, the results, and any continuing problems is crucial. Repair orders, invoices, and correspondence with repair facilities and the manufacturer help demonstrate the pattern of unsuccessful repairs and support a lemon law claim when negotiation becomes necessary.
Used RVs can be covered under California’s lemon law in certain circumstances, particularly when they are still within an original manufacturer warranty or when dealers provide express warranties. The availability of remedies depends on warranty status, mileage or hours, and the specific terms of any coverage. Santa Paula owners should review the vehicle’s warranty documents and any dealer statements to determine whether coverage applies to their situation. Even if full manufacturer coverage has expired, other consumer protection claims may be available for misrepresentation or breach of implied warranty in some transactions. Collecting sales documents, repair histories, and any warranty or dealer promises helps evaluate whether a legal claim is viable based on the specific facts of the purchase or lease.
If a vehicle is determined to be a lemon under California law, remedies can include repurchase by the manufacturer, replacement with a comparable vehicle, or monetary compensation that reflects repair costs and diminished value. The specific remedy depends on the facts, documented repairs, and applicable warranty terms. For Santa Paula RV owners, these remedies aim to make the owner whole for persistent defects that impair use or safety. Additional recoveries may include reimbursement for reasonable incidental expenses such as towing, repair-related transportation, or other documented costs tied to the defect. Presenting clear documentation of such expenses improves the chance they will be considered in settlement negotiations or formal remedies.
Time limits for pursuing a lemon law claim can vary depending on warranty terms, the date of the defect, and California’s statute of limitations for breach of warranty or consumer protection claims. For Santa Paula owners, beginning to document problems and seeking advice promptly is important to preserve rights and relevant evidence. Delays can complicate evidence collection and may affect available remedies. If you suspect your RV qualifies as a lemon, gather repair records and warranty documents and seek an evaluation as soon as possible. Early action helps ensure that time-sensitive steps are not missed and that an appropriate claim is filed within applicable deadlines under California law.
Using authorized repair facilities for warranty-covered work helps ensure the manufacturer recognizes the repairs as attempts to cure defects. For Santa Paula owners, service at authorized centers often provides clearer documentation and may prevent disputes about whether the manufacturer had a real opportunity to fix the problem. When authorized repairs are not available locally, document the reasons and keep detailed records of any alternative qualified service. Regardless of where repairs are performed, retaining invoices, work orders, and written descriptions of the work completed is essential. These records show the attempts made to repair the defect and form the foundation of any lemon law claim, especially when the issue continues despite repeated service visits.
The timeline for resolving a lemon law claim varies. Some cases resolve quickly through negotiation and a clear presentation of repair records, while others take longer if arbitration or litigation is required. For Santa Paula owners, the complexity of RV systems and the need for technical evaluations can extend the process. Being prepared with comprehensive documentation often speeds negotiations and improves prospects for a timely resolution. While formal disputes can take months to resolve, taking early steps to document repairs and communicate clearly with the manufacturer often shortens the timeline. Working with a representative who can organize records and handle communications can also reduce the time an owner must spend managing the claim.
Incidental expenses such as towing, rental vehicle costs, and other out-of-pocket charges related to repairs may be recoverable if they are reasonable and documented. Santa Paula owners should retain receipts and invoices for these costs and include them in the claim file. Well-documented incidental expenses strengthen the argument for broader compensation beyond repair costs and diminished value. Presenting these expenses clearly in negotiations or formal claims helps ensure they are considered as part of a fair remedy. Keeping precise records and explaining how these costs resulted from the defect improves the likelihood they will be included in any settlement or award.
If your motorhome keeps breaking down, begin by documenting every incident and repair attempt, including dates, descriptions of the problem, service orders, and any communications with the dealer or manufacturer. For Santa Paula owners, creating a single timeline of issues and repairs provides a clear view of the problem’s persistence and impact. Photographs and notes about when failures occurred are also helpful evidence. Next, review your warranty documents and consider seeking an evaluation to determine whether the pattern of failures warrants lemon law action. An early assessment helps preserve rights, clarifies likely remedies, and guides whether a demand to the manufacturer or more formal steps are appropriate under California law.
Law Republic APC helps Santa Paula RV owners by reviewing repair histories, warranty terms, and communications to evaluate whether a vehicle meets the conditions for a lemon law claim. We assist in organizing documentation, preparing demand letters, and negotiating with manufacturers to pursue repurchase, replacement, or monetary recovery. When technical issues are complex, we coordinate with qualified repair facilities to clarify the persistence and impact of defects. If negotiations are unsuccessful, we prepare for arbitration or litigation by compiling evidence, witness statements, and technical assessments to present a clear case. Our goal is to help owners pursue fair remedies while managing communications and preserving the owner’s rights under California law.
"*" indicates required fields